Michael Morgan
Get in touch
The receipts, not the hype

SEO ranking factors:
what Google actually confirms.

There are a thousand “ranking factor” lists, and most of them are guesses. This one only counts what Google documents, what large studies and sworn testimony show and what Google has publicly called a myth. For AI answers, see answer engine optimization.

96.55%Of pages in Ahrefs’ 14-billion-page index get zero traffic from Google.Ahrefs, 2023
58.5%Of US Google searches end without a click to anything.SparkToro and Datos, 2024
27.6%Average click-through rate for the #1 organic result, about 10x the #10 spot.Backlinko, 4M results

1What’s documented to move rankings

Fifteen things worth knowing, each with its source. Filter by how strong the evidence is.

Google documentedGoogle says so in its own Search Central docs.
Research or court recordA large study measured it, or Google engineers said it under oath. Read the caveat.
MythPopular advice Google has publicly said it doesn’t use.
Google documented

Be crawlable and indexable first

What’s documentedGoogle Search Essentials lists three technical requirements: Googlebot isn’t blocked, the page works and returns a 200 status, and it has indexable content. Nothing else matters until these are true.

Do thisOpen the Pages report in Search Console and fix the pages you care about that show “Not indexed.” It’s the least glamorous and highest-return hour in SEO.

Google Search Essentials ↗

Google documented

Write people-first content

What’s documentedGoogle’s ranking systems are designed to prioritize helpful, reliable content made for people rather than for search engines. Its guide gives a self-check: who made it, how it was made and why it exists.

Do thisShow first-hand experience, name the author and answer the question better than what already ranks. If the main reason a page exists is to rank, Google is telling you that’s the wrong reason.

Google: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content ↗

Google documented

Links still count

What’s documentedGoogle’s guide to its ranking systems says link analysis helps it understand what pages are about, and that PageRank, though much changed, is still part of its core ranking systems. Google also documents that it finds pages through crawlable links with descriptive anchor text.

Do thisEarn links by publishing things worth referencing, and link your own pages to each other with clear anchor text. Your internal links are the ones you fully control.

Google: Ranking systems guide ↗ · Link best practices ↗

Google documented

Freshness matters where searchers expect it

What’s documentedGoogle runs “query deserves freshness” systems that show fresher content for searches where newer information is expected, like news, prices or anything that changes.

Do thisKeep pages on fast-moving topics up to date with real changes. A recipe from 2015 can still rank; a 2023 software comparison probably shouldn’t.

Google: Ranking systems guide ↗

Google documented

Page experience is a signal, not a trump card

What’s documentedGoogle says Core Web Vitals are used by its ranking systems, alongside a mix of page experience signals. It also says good scores don’t guarantee good rankings.

Do thisFix pages that are clearly slow, jumpy or broken on mobile. Don’t chase a perfect 100 at the expense of better content.

Google: Understanding page experience ↗

Google documented

Stay clear of the spam policies

What’s documentedIn March 2024 Google added three named spam policies: scaled content abuse, site reputation abuse and expired domain abuse. Scaled content abuse covers mass-produced pages that add little value, whether people or AI wrote them.

Do thisBefore launching hundreds of templated or AI-written pages, ask whether each one would be worth reading if search didn’t exist.

Google: Spam policies ↗

Court record

Clicks feed rankings

What’s documentedIn the US v. Google antitrust trial, Google’s head of search quality testified about Navboost, a system that uses aggregated click data, reportedly about 13 months of it, to help rank results. He called it one important signal among many.

Caveat: testimony and trial exhibits, not documentation. Google argued click data matters less than the government claimed.

Search Engine Land: Google ranking signals from the trial ↗

Shown in research

Pages without links rarely get traffic

What’s documentedAhrefs found 96.55% of the 14 billion pages in its index get no Google traffic. Of about 20 million pages with zero referring domains, fewer than 3,000 got more than 1,000 search visits a month.

Caveat: correlation, estimated traffic and a vendor’s own index.

Ahrefs: 96.55% of content gets no traffic from Google ↗ 2023

Shown in research

The top spot gets most of the clicks

What’s documentedAcross 4 million results, the #1 organic result averaged a 27.6% click-through rate, about 10 times the #10 spot. Page two barely gets clicked at all.

Caveat: older data. Clicks drop further when an AI Overview or other features appear, so treat it as a ceiling.

Backlinko: Google CTR stats ↗

Shown in research

Google rewrites most title tags

What’s documentedAcross about 81,000 titles on 2,370 sites, Google rewrote 61.6% at least partly. Long titles, brackets and boilerplate got rewritten most. Titles that matched the H1 got rewritten less.

Caveat: one study from a single SEO firm, though earlier studies found similar patterns.

Zyppy: Google rewrites 61% of titles ↗ · Google: Title links ↗

Myth

Longer content ranks better

What’s documentedGoogle’s helpful content guide asks if you’re writing to a word count because you heard Google prefers one, and answers it directly: it doesn’t.

My takeLong pages often rank because they answer more, not because they’re long. Cut the throat-clearing intro.

Google: Creating helpful content ↗

Myth

Google gives you an E-E-A-T score

What’s documentedGoogle says E-E-A-T (experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trust) isn’t a specific ranking factor. Its systems use a mix of signals that tend to line up with it.

My takeTreat E-E-A-T as a description of a page people trust, not a checklist. Real authors, real experience and real sources do the work.

Google: Creating helpful content ↗

Myth

AI-written content gets penalized

What’s documentedGoogle’s guidance on generative AI content says AI can help research and structure original content. The problem is using it to churn out lots of pages without adding value, which falls under scaled content abuse.

My takeGoogle judges the page, not the tool. Edit hard, fact-check everything and add what only you know.

Google: Using generative AI content ↗

Myth

The meta keywords tag helps

What’s documentedGoogle said in 2009 that it doesn’t use the keywords meta tag in web ranking. It still doesn’t.

My takeIf an audit tool still flags missing meta keywords, that tells you how old the tool is.

Google Search Central blog, 2009 ↗

Myth

There’s a duplicate content penalty

What’s documentedGoogle has said there’s no duplicate content penalty for normal duplication. It picks one version to show, and only acts when duplication is meant to manipulate results.

My takeThe real cost is diluted signals. Use canonical tags so Google credits the version you want.

Google: Demystifying the duplicate content penalty ↗

2Where to start

If you only do three things this quarter, do these, in this order.

1

Fix what blocks you

Indexing errors, broken pages, slow mobile templates and pages Google can’t reach through links. Search Console shows you all of it for free.

2

Pick queries you can win

Start with questions your buyers actually ask that you can answer better than anyone ranking now. A page-one spot on a niche question beats page three on a big one.

3

Earn links and mentions

Original data, useful tools, guest appearances and partner pages. Things people reference on their own, because that’s what links and mentions are.

The short version: SEO is the foundation of AI visibility too. Google’s AI answers draw on the same index, so the work compounds. See what’s documented for AEO →

3How to measure SEO

Rankings are a means. Pipeline is the point.

Free · first-party

Search Console Performance

Clicks, impressions, click-through rate and average position by query and page. Look for queries with impressions and no clicks: that’s your fastest win list.

Free · first-party

Search Console Pages

Which pages are indexed, which aren’t and why. Check it after every launch, because nothing ranks from outside the index.

How I do it

Organic pipeline in the CRM

Track organic-sourced and organic-influenced pipeline, not just sessions. If SEO traffic grows and pipeline doesn’t, you’re ranking for the wrong things. Compare attribution models →

Frequently asked questions

What are the most important Google ranking factors?

Google doesn’t publish weights, but its own docs name the big systems: relevance to the query, helpful people-first content, links (PageRank is still part of core ranking), freshness where it matters, page experience and spam detection. Court testimony from the US v. Google trial added that user click data feeds a system called Navboost.

Is SEO dead because of AI search?

No, but clicks are harder to earn. Google says its AI Overviews and AI Mode use the same index and have no extra requirements beyond being indexed and eligible for a snippet, so SEO is the foundation of AI visibility. What’s changed is that more searches end without a click, so brand mentions and measurement matter more.

Does word count matter for SEO?

Not by itself. Google’s helpful content guidance says it has no preferred word count. Write as long as the answer needs and no longer.

Is AI-generated content bad for SEO?

Not because it’s AI. Google says it rewards helpful content however it’s made. What breaks its spam policy is scaled content abuse: publishing lots of pages, with or without AI, that add little value for readers.

How long does SEO take to work?

Google’s own guidance on hiring an SEO says it typically takes four months to a year to implement improvements and start seeing benefit. Technical fixes can show up faster; authority takes longer.

Sources

  1. Google Search Essentials, Google Search Central.
  2. Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content, Google Search Central.
  3. A guide to Google Search ranking systems, Google Search Central.
  4. Link best practices for Google, Google Search Central.
  5. Understanding page experience in Google Search results, Google Search Central.
  6. Spam policies for Google web search, Google Search Central.
  7. Google Search’s guidance on using generative AI content, Google Search Central.
  8. Influencing your title links, Google Search Central.
  9. Do you need an SEO?, Google Search Central.
  10. Google does not use the keywords meta tag in web ranking, Google, 2009.
  11. Demystifying the “duplicate content penalty”, Google, 2008.
  12. The ABCs of Google ranking signals: what top search engineers revealed, Search Engine Land, on US v. Google trial testimony.
  13. 96.55% of content gets no traffic from Google, Ahrefs, December 2023.
  14. Nearly 60% of Google searches end without a click, Search Engine Land on SparkToro and Datos, 2024.
  15. Google organic click-through rate stats (4M results), Backlinko.
  16. Google rewrites 61% of page title tags, Zyppy.

More free tools

Want search to show up in pipeline?

Brand, demand and the systems that measure it.

Let’s talk

“Fix what’s underneath, and the rest gets easier.”Michael Morgan